[HaRvEy]

Club: NEWCASTLE UNITED

Star players: SHAY GIVEN, SCOTT PARKER, STEVEN TAYLOR, MICHAEL OWEN, ALAN SHEARER, EMRE, NOBBY, N'ZOGBIA, PETER RABBIT, KIERON DYER

Dead wood: Babayaro, Elliott, Carr., Chopra

Players who are average: Babayaro, Carr

Who would you buy: Wayne Bridge, Ronaldinho, Joaquin

Who would you sell: Babayaro, Carr, Chopra

Is your manager doing the right job: who knows

This post has been edited by Santa HaRv: 13 December 2005 - 09:54 AM

[Agent Provocateur]

Club: Liverpool

Star players: Jamie Carragher, Luis Garcia, Steven Gerrard, Xabi Alonso, Peter Crouch, Steve Finnan, Sami

Dead wood: Jerzy Dudek,

Players who are average: Fernando Morientes, John Arne Riise,

Who would you buy: Daniel Agger, Simao, Joaquin, Michael Owen.

Who would you sell: Djimi Traore, Jerzy Dudek, Anthony Le Tallec, Djibril Cisse, Fernando Morientes

Is your manager doing the right job: Yes, he's doing a superb job. After an awful start to the season we're really starting to look like what we are - the Champions of Europe.

Is he playing anyone he shouldnt or not playing someone he should: No, I'm happy with the team, we just need to tidy up to get ourselves further up the field. I'm fairly happy though. We have a good squad. Anyone who says otherwise is a Communist.

[LoRezz]

Players who are average: Lee Bowyer, Jean Alain Boumsong, Celestine Babayaro, Titus Bramble , Albert Luque

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

OMG. Do you watch the same games as me!! Him And Boumsong are Diabolical Liberties To your squad - Lucky u got Shay Given between the sticks!!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

9 clean sheets this season in all comps, our center backs are nowhere near as bad as people think, sure they have made mistakes in big games, like gifting Manchester United a win against us, but they rarly get praise for games where they shut the other team out.


If you watch titus play week in week out you'll see how good he is in the air and tackling, the only bad part of his game is he usually makes one "concentration" error every game which means we either concede or shay makes a super save.

[HaRvEy]

Newcastle's problem is scoring goals not concieding them

[StepoverMaster]

Even with Owen, Shearer, Solano, Emre, and Luque?

[LoRezz]

Solano, has been injured, and since he got back from injury has been average at best in most games,

Luque - injured has played 1 full game and a hand full of clearly not fully fit sub apperances,

Emre - he's doing fine for the number of apperances 2 assists and 2 goals,

Owen - 6 games 4 goals is good return and once he's playing regularly he's going to get us goals

Shearers play is now more that of supporting striker, hold up ball and pass it off to the shot taker which when its amiobi we're screwed



We need owen, luque and emre fit to be a credible attacking force, and so far these 3 have not played a single game with all of them on the pitch i believe.

Basically we have the quality we just need a bit more in reserve who can come in when we have injurys.

[RobertNUFC]

Club: Newcastle

Star players: Parker, Owen, Shearer, Given, N'Zogbia, Emre

Dead wood: Titus Bramble, Amdy Faye.
Players who are average: Faye, Bramble, Elliot, Carr.

Who would you buy: Woodgate, Andrade, any defender with any sort of talent to partner boumsong.
Who would you sell: Amdy Faye.

Is your manager doing the right job: No, he can'thandle the pressure, and just isn't up to the job. We pay top money for players but not the manager and thats why hes in charge.
Is he playing anyone he shouldnt or not playing someone he should: We pay 9.5 million for Luque, yet ameobi starts ahead of him

[Blunose]

Club: Biiiirmingham City

Star players: :eusa_think: Is there anyone? Heskey and Dunn I suppose.

Dead wood: Olivier 'Bombscare' Tebily, Jiri 'I'm leaving on a jetplane' Jarosik.

Players who are average: Stephen Clemence, Damo Jonty.

Who would you buy: Nathan Tyson, Bergdolmo.

Who would you sell: Bombscare, and send Jiri back to rot in Chelsea's reserves.

Is your manager doing the right job: I'll tell you in a couple of matches time, we won but now we need to keep winning ;)

[Agent Provocateur]

Who would you buy: Woodgate, Andrade, any defender with any sort of talent to partner boumsong.
[

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'd argue that you need to ship Boumsong out and get 2 central defenders, myself.

[Honking Antelope]

Club: Newcastle United

Star players: Alan Shearer, Shay Given, Belazoglu Emre, Nobby Solano, Michael Owen, Scott Parker, Steven Taylor

Dead wood: Amdy Faye, Shola Ameobi, Graeme Souness

Players who are average: Lee Bowyer, Jean Alain Boumsong, Celestine Babayaro, Titus Bramble, Albert Luque

Who would you buy: Joaquin, Daniel van Buyton, Nicolas Anelka, Some more defenders

Who would you sell: Amdy Faye

Is your manager doing the right job: Not at all.  We've got a brilliant squad, and we're about 6-7 places below what we should be.

Is he playing anyone he shouldnt or not playing someone he should: Amdy Faye

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

havent you seen the last 2 games :coffee:

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Haven't you seen the last 12 months?

[cubskeeper]

Club: Manchester United Football Club

Star Players: van der Sar, Heinze, Ronaldo, Rooney, van Nistelrooy

Dead wood: Fortune, Miller, Silvestre

Players who are average: Fletcher, Smith, John O'Shea, Brown

Who would you buy: Vincent Kompany, Nigel de Jong, Mascherano (unlikely to happen)

Who would you sell: Fortune, Miller, Silvestre

Is your manager doing the right job: I don't think it's fair to say that Sir Alex is doing a poor job, we are rebuilding, we are in between great teams, and Fergie is hands down the best manager in the history of football. Fans aren't getting behind the team and it could be affecting performance, true fans don't boo their team off the pitch.

Is he playing anyone he shouldnt or not playing someone he should: Not really. Smithy looks good in defensive midfield... he shouldn't play Ronaldo or Park up top but that is sort of rare.

Thoughts: SACK QUIEROZ! Hire Keano as assistant in a couple years, or Cantona if the Glazers leave, since he won't work under them.

This post has been edited by cubskeeper: 17 December 2005 - 03:46 PM